20 Best Cruelty Free Toothpaste Brands For Sensitive Teeth
Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links, meaning we receive a commission if you decide to make a purchase through our links, but this is at no additional cost to you. Please read our disclosure for more info.
There are many factors to consider when searching for a cruelty-free toothpaste. While everyone has their own specific needs and favorite flavors, it helps to have a few recommendations — and that’s just what we’ve done here.
There are a ton of cruelty-free toothpaste brands on the market at the moment, so it’s a bit difficult to immediately be able to differentiate between the two. Luckily, we’ve done it for you!
Below you’ll be able to find our 20 favorite vegan toothpaste from a variety of different brands. We’ve also created pros and cons lists for each individual item, so you can best find the toothpaste for your lifestyle!
Best Cruelty Free Toothpaste Brands
Jason's Natural | ||
Dr. Bronner's | ||
Nature's Gate | ||
Hello Toothpaste | ||
Himalaya Complete Care | ||
Desert Essence | ||
Dr. Sharp | ||
Tom's of Maine | ||
David's Premium | ||
Cleure |
Uncle Harry's | ||
WITH MY | ||
Vita-myr | ||
Now Foods | ||
Kiss My Face | ||
Auromere | ||
Dr. Brite | ||
Primal Life Organics | ||
Redmonds | ||
Living Libations |
Best Cruelty Free Toothpaste Brands
Jason's Natural | |
Dr. Bronner's | |
Nature's Gate | |
Hello Toothpaste | |
Himalaya Complete Care | |
Desert Essence | |
Dr. Sharp | |
Tom's Of Maine | |
David's Premium | |
Cleure | |
Uncle Harry's | |
WITH MY | |
Vita-myr | |
Now Foods | |
Kiss My Face | |
Auromere | |
Dr. Brite | |
Primal Life Organics | |
Redmonds | |
Living Libations |
1. Jason Natural Sea Fresh Toothpaste
A longtime beauty brand staple for those who use all-natural ingredients, Jason’s has been using only organic ingredients from their inception in 1959. Beloved by many, this toothpaste (which comes in many flavors) has users hooked, as it keeps their mouth clean and fresh. Gluten-free and made without any toxins or harsh chemicals, Jason pastes only have a few natural ingredients.
Verdict: Best tasting natural toothpaste
Pros:
- No artificial sweeteners, fluorides, or other toxins
- Made with baking soda and calcium carbonate
- All flavors in the Jason brand are well-received
Cons:
- Some users don’t love the texture, as it’s more of a paste (and less of a gel)
2. Dr. Bronner's Peppermint All-One Toothpaste
You may have heard of the organic beauty brand Dr Bronner’s before, as they’re one of the most recognized brands in the country. From toothpaste to body wash to chapstick, Dr Bronner’s is a beloved brand. Their toothpaste is no different, as many users believe that it’s the best cruelty-free toothpaste that truly cleans your whole mouth.
Verdict: Best paste to truly clean your teeth and leave you feeling fresh
Pros:
- Cleans your teeth, fights plaque, and leaves your breath (and whole mouth, teeth and gums included!) feeling fresh
- The packaging of this product is made from 100% recyclable material
- Made free of fluoride, sulfates, and other toxins
Cons:
- Slightly more expensive than other pastes on this list
3. Nature's Gate Natural Toothpaste
Nature’s Gate Natural Toothpaste is possibly one of the most beloved cruelty-free (and vegan!) toothpaste on the market — especially their creme de peppermint flavor. A longtime vegan company, you can buy these popular pastes either in bulk or in one size. Made in America, this toothpaste is made naturally and created free of fluoride.
Verdict: Best flavor made with natural ingredients
Pros:
- While Nature’s Gate has many different flavors, their most beloved taste is their creme de peppermint flavor
- Created free of toxins like fluoride, as well as other harsh chemicals
- Made in America
- Helps to naturally strengthen gums and teeth, while also fighting plaque
Cons:
- Some flavors have a very strong smell that users don’t like (the wintergreen flavor seems to be the worst)
4. Hello Toothpaste
Hello Toothpaste, out of all of the cruelty-free toothpaste brands on this list, is possibly the best designed and best-marketed brand. It also happens to be quite a good organic business! Hello Toothpaste has many different flavors and types to choose from, and they even have a toothpaste line for kids!
Verdict: Best brand whose products all help naturally whiten teeth
Pros:
- Helps to naturally fight plaque and whiten teeth
- Made of all-natural ingredients (which also includes farm-grown peppermint!)
- Fluoride and dye-free
- Made in America
Cons:
- A relatively gentle toothpaste line, this isn’t the best paste for users who like a deep clean
5. Himalaya Complete Care Toothpaste
An organic paste, the Himalaya Complete Care Toothpaste has been created by a family-owned business since 1930. Users who have used this paste love how it naturally whitens their teeth. Made with toxin-free ingredients, this toothpaste is also cheaper than many other naturally made pastes on the market.
Verdict: Best toothpaste that naturally whitens your teeth
Pros:
- Helps to naturally whiten your teeth
- Organic and created with natural ingredients
- Free of toxins and harsh chemicals
- Cheaper price point than other items on this list
Cons:
- Some users feel this toothpaste didn’t rid their teeth of all plaque
6. Desert Essence Natural Tea Tree Oil Toothpaste
A vegan toothpaste that truly deep cleans your mouth? Say it ain’t so! Many users find it difficult to find all-natural pastes that leave their mouth feeling clean (and not gritty), but this Desert Essence Toothpaste has rave reviews in this regard. It’s possibly the best organic toothpaste to use if you like a deep clean every day. However, some users particularly don’t like the flavor, which can cancel out how great the deep clean is.
Verdict: Best paste that deep cleans your mouth and gums
Pros:
- Out of possibly all the other natural pastes on this list, this product is the best at truly deep cleaning your mouth
- Made with nothing but natural ingredients (and also gluten-free!)
Cons:
- Slightly more expensive than other pastes on this list
- Some users don’t love the taste
7. Dr. Sharp Natural Oral Care Toothpaste
Dr. Sharp’s Natural Oral Care Toothpaste is one of the best-tasting pastes around — and boy do they last a long time! A little goes a long way with this toothpaste, which is great because it can run slightly more expensive than others on the market. Made without any toxins or chemicals, this toothpaste leaves your mouth clean and fights plaque and bacteria.
Verdict: Best toothpaste where a little goes a long way
Pros:
- A little goes a long way with this toothpaste, so you’ll have one tube for a long time
- Their packaging is made of recyclable material
- Created without fluoride and other harsh chemicals and toxins
- Comes in great flavors
- A PETA certified cruelty-free product
Cons:
- Some users have complained about the packaging, as it appears to easily fall apart
- Can run a bit more expensive than other products on this list
8. Tom's of Maine Antiplaque and Whitening Flouride-Free Natural Toothpaste
Tom’s of Maine has been a beauty staple for those looking for all-natural products for decades now. The company also donates a portion of its proceeds to charity! With their consistent production of pastes made with natural ingredients (and no harsh chemicals and toxins), Tom’s of Maine tends to be the immediate go-to for many.
Verdict: Best for those with sensitive teeth
Pros:
- Made with all-natural ingredients — and no toxins!
- Created with no artificial dyes or sweeteners, making it great for those with sensitive teeth
- Both fluoride and gluten-free
- Helps to naturally fight plaque
Cons:
- While the company has many different flavors, many users find them to be relatively bland
9. David's Premium Natural Toothpaste
David's Premium Natural Toothpaste is one of the most organic products in the cruelty-free toothpaste category. With an EWG rating of one, this item is perfect for those who value transparency from organic businesses. Plus, this product is also created with recyclable material.
Verdict: Best toothpaste for those looking for something incredibly organic
Pros:
- Has an EWG rating of one (which means the product is very organic, and the business is very transparent with their ingredients)
- Created with recyclable packaging
- Made in America
Cons:
- Slightly pricier than others on this list
10. Cleure Original Unflavored Paste
Cleure’s Original Unflavored Paste is created without the minty flavor that many regular kinds of toothpaste have. However, minty flavors have been known to cause allergy flare-ups and inflammation in those with sensitive teeth. Therefore, Cleure has become a go-to for those with sensitive mouths.
Verdict: Best for those sensitive teeth
Pros:
- Because of the ingredients (and also because it doesn’t have a flavor), this Cleure toothpaste is perfect for those with more sensitive teeth
- Made with no harsh chemicals
- Gluten-free, cruelty-free, natural, and organic
Cons:
- Because it’s unflavored, some may not love the taste and may prefer a toothpaste that has a more minty flavor
11. Uncle Harry's Flouride Free Toothpaste
A cruelty-free toothpaste that comes in a jar, Uncle Harry’s Flouride Free Toothpaste is 100% vegan. While slightly pricier than your average toothpaste, a little goes a long way with this vegan product.
Verdict: Best for fresh breath
Pros:
- Keeps your breath smelling fresh long after you use it
- Helps strengthen your teeth while also fighting bacteria (more so than other toothpaste on this list)
Cons:
- Slightly pricier than other items on this list
12. WITH MY Cruelty-Free Lemonade Flavor
A toothpaste brand that both donates to charity and creates their products with recyclable packaging, WITH MY’s lemonade flavor toothpaste is a favorite for many. If you hate regular old minty paste, this product will become your new best friend.
Verdict: Best tasting toothpaste + best for those who try to buy recycled material as much as possible
Pros:
- Perfect for those who hate minty flavored toothpaste
- Donates a portion of their proceeds to charity
- Created with recyclable packaging
Cons:
- Slightly pricier than other items on this list
13. Vita-myr Zinc-Plus Herbal Paste
Vita-myr Zinc-Plus Herbal Paste has been a fan favorite vegan toothpaste for years now. It’s been tested on adults (not animals!) for a long time to make sure that no side effects occur. It also happens to be one of the best pastes for those looking for absolutely no chemicals or toxins in their product.
Verdict: Best natural cruelty-free toothpaste made with no toxins or chemicals
Pros:
- Created with no harsh chemicals — no fluoride, sugar, SLS, or saccharine
- Created by Yvonne Takhtalian, a renowned herbal specialist
Cons:
- Slightly pricier than others on this list
14. Now Foods Xyli White Platnium Mint Flavor
A natural toothpaste that those with sensitive teeth swear by, Now Foods’ paste is great for those who want to take care of their teeth naturally, yet also whiten them. It’s also a great toothpaste for those who don’t want to spend a lot of money on something toxin-free.
Verdict: Best toothpaste to help whiten your teeth
Pros:
- Helps whiten your teeth naturally while also keeping them fresh and clean
- Created without toxins and harsh chemicals
- Great, cheap price for the quality of the product
Cons:
- Has a mild taste (those who want a strong, minty flavor may be disappointed)
15. Kiss My Face Triple Action Gel Toothpaste
Another natural beauty brand that has been around for a few decades now, Kiss My Face has more than a few toothpaste flavors to its name. However, one thing all their pastes have in common is their amazing ability to help users reduce their painful teeth sensitivity. Made without fluoride and other toxins, this cruelty-free toothpaste is highly regarded.
Verdict: Best toothpaste that helps reduce teeth sensitivity
Pros:
- One of the only natural pastes around that is known to greatly help users with painful teeth sensitivity
- Many users love the flavors available
- No fluoride, artificial colors or sweeteners
Cons:
- Some users feel that it didn’t help naturally whiten teeth in any capacity
16. Auromere
An ayurvedic herbal toothpaste, Auromere is created without mint, eucalyptus, or menthol. Instead, the toothpaste brand creates their products with naturally sweetened licorice root, as well as 24 special herbal extracts. This paste lasts a long time and is perfect for those who don’t necessarily love minty toothpaste flavors.
Verdict: Best flavor for those who don’t like minty toothpaste
Pros:
- Has a great flavor that isn’t minty (toothpaste isn’t made with mint, eucalyptus, or menthol)
- Gluten-free, fluoride-free, GMO-free, and made without any toxins
- A little goes a long way (so the toothpaste lasts quite a long time)
Cons:
- Slightly more expensive than other products on this list
17. Dr. Brite
Dr. Brite’s toothpaste is a great organic paste (made with all-natural ingredients) that helps keep your mouth clean and fresh. More specifically, users overwhelming believe that this cruelty-free toothpaste is perfect for those looking to target their gums. However, the toothpaste also helps whiten your teeth and is gentle enough for even kids to use!
Verdict: Best for those looking for a toothpaste specifically for healthy gums
Pros:
- A great toothpaste if you’re looking for a paste that helps your gums
- Great for both adults and children to use
- Helps to naturally whiten teeth, as well as keep gums healthy
- Made with no artificial sweeteners or colors
Cons:
- Slightly more expensive than other products on the market
18. Dirty Mouth Organic Toothpowder by Primal Life Organics
Dirty Mouth Organic Toothpowder is a bit unusual, as its a powder (not a gel or paste). Made with earthen clays and essential oils, this organic and all-natural toothpowder has become a go-to for people who are looking to remineralize their teeth. However, it’s also known as a powder than helps to naturally whiten teeth over time!
Verdict: Best toothpaste that helps to remineralize your teeth
Pros:
- Gluten-free, and made with earthen clays and essential oils
- Helps to naturally whiten teeth over time
- Made with organic ingredients
Cons:
- Users don’t love the tastes available, and some say all they can taste is baking soda
19. Earthpaste by Redmonds
One of the only toothpaste products to be made without both fluoride and glycerin, Earthpaste by Redmonds has become popular for people who want only a few ingredients in their toothpaste. Earthpaste is more of a clay, so it is a bit messier than a regular gel toothpaste. However, users swear by this product for themselves, as well as for their kids!
Verdict: Best toothpaste with the fewest, most natural ingredients
Pros:
- Only made with a few, natural ingredients
- Made with no toxins or harsh chemicals (including no fluoride or glycerin)
- It’s safe to swallow — and great for kids to use
- Helps keep mouth healthy, as well as whiten teeth
Cons:
- As it’s more of a clay texture, some users have found it annoyingly messy to use
20. Organic/Wildcrafted Frankincense Fresh Truth Toothpaste by Living Libations
If you’re looking for a toothpaste that polishes your teeth and leaves them looking as shiny as ever, look no further. Living Libations’ Toothpaste keeps your gums healthy, your mouth clean, and your smile shiny. While some users don’t love the taste, many agree that the flavor doesn’t matter as the end result is well worth the unsatisfactory taste.
Verdict: Best toothpaste that polishes your teeth
Pros:
- A gentle, natural toothpaste to use for those with more sensitive teeth
- Fluoride, sulfate, and paraben-free
- Helps keep your gums healthy, as well as your teeth naturally white
Cons:
- A bit pricier than other options on this list
- Some users haven’t loved the overall taste
The Buyer’s Guide to Cruelty-Free Toothpaste in 2020
As you search for a cruelty-free toothpaste, there are a few things you should look for — and a few things you should look out for. There are many ingredients that you can find in vegan pastes, but there are just as many ingredients to beware of. For a guideline, follow this list.
Amazing Ingredients That You’ll Love:
- Baking soda helps polish teeth, as well as naturally whiten them
- Stevia fights bacteria and helps prevent tooth decay, gingivitis, and cavities
- Xylitol helps repair damage to the enamel on your teeth
- Neem Leaf Extract helps prevent and heal gum disease and eliminates bacteria that causes gum inflammation
Horrible Ingredients to Look Out For If You Can:
- Glycerin, which can be sourced from both animal or plant products (and it can be difficult to find out if it’s animal-based or not), is said to demineralize teeth
- Carrageenan, a thickener found in foods, is linked to intestinal inflammation and cancer
- Triclosan, a pesticide found in many different pastes, is linked to antibiotic resistance
- Diethanolamine (DEA) is linked to hormone disruption
Conclusion
There are so many different factors to choose from when searching for your next, all-natural, cruelty-free toothpaste. While there are some great pastes out there, it really does depend on your own specific taste and what you currently need. Luckily, there are great vegan brands out there that produce high-quality products! With this list, hopefully you can find the cruelty-free toothpaste that you’ve been looking for.
FAQ’s
Are the most popular brands cruelty-free?
For the most part… no. The most popular toothpaste brands out on the market (like Colgate and Oral-B) aren’t cruelty-free pastes, unfortunately. These brands still use ingredients that aren’t great, as well as test their products on animals.
While this is obviously unfortunate, there are a ton of other companies and brands that have decided to adopt a cruelty-free outlook (all of which you can see above). Plus, there are even some brands that aren’t too expensive and are even averaged at the same price as what users pay for pastes like Colgate!
Are all cruelty-free pastes good for those with sensitive teeth to use?
While most cruelty-free toothpaste brands have less harsh chemicals than more popular brands, some pastes can still be a bit harsh for those with sensitive teeth to use. It really just depends on a user to user basis. After all, everyone’s different.
However, if you’re really concerned, look for pastes made specifically for those with sensitive teeth in mind. Above, you can see that the Kiss My Face Triple Action Gel Toothpaste and the Cleure Original Unflavored Paste are just two options!
Can children use cruelty-free toothpaste?
Yes! However, not all cruelty-free pastes are safe for children to use. Before use, check to see if the brand explains whether or not children can use it.
Many cruelty-free brands actually make toothpaste specifically for children and toddlers. Most notably, Tom’s of Maine makes relatively popular toothpaste options specifically made for children under a certain age.
Now It's Your Turn
Now I’d like to hear from you:
Which cruelty free toothpaste brand are you going to try out?
Do you have any opinions on these brands?
Either way, leave me a quick comment below to let me know.